Click here for home page

Click here



Contact Us | Customer Information | Privacy Policy | Audio Help

Explore
Main Menu
Submit a review
Album Reviews
Book Reviews
DVD Reviews
Sign up for newsletter
Interviews
Gig reviews
Get Your EMail Address
Submit your website
SIN-Atra Armoury Records (2011)

The brainchild of Bob Kulick (Meat Loaf/Balance et al) and Brett Chassen, this album is a metal tribute to Frank Sinatra.

This is no cheap tribute featuring former 80's hair metal has-beens like you can find on other tribute albums, as there are some top name vocalists on here including Dee Snider, Geoff Tate and Glenn Hughes. The backing band features Mr Bassman himself Billy Sheenan and Doug Katsarios (who is a member of Balance with Kulick and Chassen).

 

Bob Kulick has worked with Meat Loaf, Kiss, Balance, Skull and many more besides, along with a serious of popular tribute albums.

The latest of these is a reworking of songs associated with Frank Sinatra. The album entitled ‘Sin-Atra’ features a whole host of top draw rock and metal vocalists including Geoff Tate, Dee Snider, Anthrax’s Joey Belladonna, Mr Big’s Eric Martin and Devin Townsend who does a show stealing version of ‘New York New York’.


How did you come up with the ides of this tribute?


It came about after the Christmas album where we took all those great Christmas songs and turned them into something totally different where people had never heard them that way before. Lemmy, Dave Grohl and Billy Gibbons doing 'Run Rudolph Run' and the great Ronnie Dio, may he rest in peace, doing 'God Rest Yee Merry Gentlemen' with Vinnie Appice and Rudy Sarzo. We took that kind of formula as a way to take on of these Frank Sinatra songs and turn it into something it was never conceived for without reinventing it.

This is a rearrangement in a rock and metal way of some of the greatest songs ever written, rivalling even some of the Beatles songs.

Who came up with the idea of using Devin Townsend on 'New York New York'? That is a stroke of genius and an excellent version.

It was one of the last songs we recorded where we realised that unless we had the perfect singer, as it is the most famous Frank Sinatra song, it wouldn't sound right.

After listening to some of his albums that's when we realised Devin would be prefect for this song. He was one of the artists who couldn't come to the studio, most of the artists could. We had to trust he knew what to do as we supplied the track and backing, he did all of the vocal arrangements.

I remember the look on our faces when we got it back, one of the happiest moments as the guy totally made it his. That was the big lesson from this record, in that Frank Sinatra never wrote any of these songs, not a lick, not a melody.

But what he did do was make those his and made it his, so you believed every lyric he sang. Devin Townsend did this on this version and you can see online Devin Townsend kicks Frank Sinatra's ass all over 'New York New York'.

I wanted to see people who were excited to put their stamp on these songs as we were. To do the Frankenstein job and make them into something new.


Do you have an idea in your head who you want to sing a particular song? Or do you see who is available, or do people come to you?

All of the above but mainly we try to concoct what the style of the song we want and make a list of who we want to sing it.

We came up with the 'Summer Wind' arrangement we thought Geoff Tate, here was somebody who could totally song this tune and be recognisable from the beginning and to be hold those notes.

We sent it too him, he usually likes to think about things and take his time responding but he came back to me straight away saying 'That is an insane arrangement, I have to sing that song.'

I wanted to see people who were excited to put their stamp on these songs as we were. To do the Frankenstein job and make them into something new. I love it, I would put a track on and people would say what the heck is that? It's 'Fly Me To The Moon'!

Funny you should mention that track. I am a big Cheap Trick fan and you wouldn't know it was Robin Zander, as his vocal style is very different.

We kind of pushed him. We had a good weapon between Devin Townsend and Glenn Hughes. Whenever there was an issue with a couple of guys who sang good but we played there songs and they'd realise good is not even close enough.

We'd say to them you haven't made the song yours yet. Once they heard that they really went out and sang their balls off!

I remember seeing Glenn Hughes at Wendy Dio's New Year's Eve party and him saying to me 'So I hear you terrorised everybody with my vocal I hear'. (Laughs) All the guys called him up saying we heard what you did with 'I've Got You Under My Skin' we had to go and change our performance.

'Witchcraft' with Tim 'Ripper' Owens is the most metal song and you wouldn't even know it was a song sung previously by Sinatra.

That was a song was not on the original list as you couldn't say it was one of his biggest hits but the lyric meant it was a song to be hammered.

We finally figured out Ripper Owens was the one to do the hammering! To me that track really came out amazing – the huge power chords, the way the orchestration sits in there. One of my favourite pieces and one of my favourite singers.

The one song rock fans may know if they don't know Sinatra is 'That's Life', made famous by Dave Lee Roth. How hard was it for Jani Laine to cover this one as many rock fans may thinks it's a Dave Lee Roth song.

Jani had come to the studio and had done things with us previously. He's a tremendously talented guy, given a bad rap by being in a band that really is not as good as he is.

I love them all but Jani Laine is extremely talented. At the time he was having a bunch of personal problems and asked specifically if he could sing that song.

It was perfect as we wanted him. If someone's life was in turmoil they would really bring themselves into the song like Frank did and that was the goal.

Ripper he totally did, Glenn Hughes, a couple of the other guys needed prodding. I had to get the cattle prod out a couple of times but the end results your hearing are worth it.

I have seen online comments saying Frank must be spinning in his grave but I didn't see that, I saw Cole Porter and other great songwriters standing their like the apparitions at the end of 'Star Wars '- Yoda, Darth Vader – watching the celebration that was what we saw. We know Frank hated rock music stylistically.

The label were like 'what?' when we pitched this album. But we said its not going to be cookie monsters but guys that can sing. They were happy to hear that.
 

There are it has to be said some sheer moments of genius on here as Devin Townsend makes 'New York New York' his own complete with a couple of his trademark growls thrown in. Glenn Hughes sings 'I've Got You Under My Skin' in his own imitable style whilst Mr Big's Eric Martin has fun with 'The Lady Is A Tramp'. A couple don't work so well for me, namely Cheap Trick's Robin Zander on 'Fly Me To The Moon' on which his voice sounds distorted and the backing keys/horns detract from the tune.

Tim 'Ripper' Owens gives a suitably metal vocal to 'Witchcraft', leabing the listener wondering how the heck Frank Sinatra would have ever sung this tune. 'That's Life' will forever be Dave Lee Roth for me so sadly Jani Lane is a pale imitation and lags the playboy swagger of Mr Roth. Dug Pinnick (King's X) on 'I've Got The World On A String' and Geoff Tate on 'Summer Wind' both give strong performances as well.

The parping horns/keys can be a bit overbearing in parts but you will be amazed at how well these standards fare given a metal treatment featuring plenty of guitars.

This won't be for everybody and doubtless listeners will be driven by the vocalists they enjoy. Definitely worth a listen if one or more of the vocalists you enjoy are on here and I am sure the labum will bring in new listeners to rock/metal music given the Sinatra link. Not sure what Ol' Blue Eyes would have made of this although Dee Snider seems to think he would have fronted a metal band!

***

Review by Jason Ritchie

 


Print this page in printer friendly format

Print this page in printer-friendly format



***** Out of this world | **** Pretty damn fine |
*** OK, approach with caution unless you are a fan |
** Instant bargain bin fodder | * Ugly. Just ugly

get ready to rock is a division of hotdigitsnewmedia group

Featured Artists
Artist Archive
Featured Labels
Label Archive
Do you want to appear here?